Skip to content

PLC output off, relay still on? How flyback diodes affect release time

A flyback diode protects a DC relay driver, but it can slow coil-current decay. Follow the current path, compare clamp voltages and locate the delay before changing PLC timing.

Xindustra Editorial Team
Published October 16, 2026
10 min read
DC relay coil and parallel flyback diode, showing how current persists after driver turn-off.

The PLC output indicator goes dark, but the relay contact opens a little later. After a relay or socket replacement, that delay may become noticeable enough to upset a sequence. The first question is not whether the program needs a shorter timer. It is whether removing the drive has actually removed the magnetic force holding the relay in.

A DC relay coil stores energy. A flyback diode gives the coil current a path after the driver switches off, protecting the switching device from a large transient. That same path can let current—and magnetic force—persist longer. The relay can therefore release later even though the PLC has already removed its command.

This explanation uses an ordinary, non-latching DC interposing relay controlled by a transistor output. The drawing uses a low-side driver to make the current path clear; it is not a PLC terminal diagram. The timing analysis concerns ordinary control sequencing, not validation of a safety-related stopping function.

The driver is off, but the coil current still has somewhere to go

While the driver is on, current flows from the supply through the coil and the driver to the return. A correctly oriented diode across the coil is reverse-biased: its cathode, K, is at the positive coil connection and its anode, A, is at the driver side. It does not normally conduct across the energized coil.

When the driver opens, the coil opposes the fall in current by reversing its terminal voltage. The driver-side coil connection rises above the positive supply rail until the diode conducts. Current then circulates through the coil and diode, continuing through the coil in the same direction as before. The switch is open; the stored magnetic energy is supplying this short-lived current.

Follow the orange arrows in the lower panel. They form a local loop around the coil and diode, rather than requiring a closed driver switch.

Two states of a low-side DC relay circuit. With the driver on, the parallel diode blocks. Just after switch-off, current continues through the coil and returns through the diode from anode to cathode.
Figure 1. Functional current paths for a DC coil with a parallel flyback diode. The diode is shown as a labeled component block: K is cathode and A is anode. After turn-off, conventional current continues downward through the coil and returns upward through the diode. The supply connection remains present, but the driver is open. This is not a manufacturer terminal assignment.

The diode limits the reverse voltage across the coil to approximately its forward drop while it conducts. Energy is dissipated in the coil resistance and diode, so current decays instead of stopping instantly. Omron describes this energy path and its effect on release time in its surge-suppressor comparison3. A plain parallel diode is a DC arrangement; the same connection is unsuitable across an AC coil.

Protection and fast release pull in different directions

A small reverse coil voltage is gentle on the driver, but it also permits a relatively slow decay of current. A suitable higher-voltage suppressor lets the coil develop a larger reverse voltage, dissipating its stored energy more quickly. One arrangement is a rectifier diode in series with an oppositely oriented Zener diode: the branch blocks normal supply current, then conducts through the rectifier and the Zener’s breakdown path at turn-off.

This is a design trade-off, not permission to remove protection. The driver, relay, suppressor and wiring must tolerate the resulting transient. A module may already include a clamp, and an external low-voltage diode can become the dominant freewheel path even when a higher clamp exists elsewhere. Identify the actual suppression circuit before changing components.

In TE’s DC relay suppression note1, the release behavior is also tied to contact motion and load switching. TE discusses how slower opening can contribute to intermittent sticking of normally-open contacts under some loads. It separately notes that retarded motion can reduce closing bounce for some normally-closed applications. A faster clamp is therefore not automatically the best choice for every relay and contact duty.

A calculation that shows the trade-off without predicting contact time

Consider an idealized 24 V coil represented by a constant 4 H inductance and 400 Ω resistance. At steady state, its current is 24 / 400 = 0.060 A, or 60 mA. Its stored energy is E = ½LI² = 0.0072 J, or 7.2 mJ. These are assumed example values, not specifications for a particular relay.

Compare the time for current to fall from 60 mA to an arbitrary 15 mA marker. That marker is not a specified dropout current. Treat the reverse clamp voltage across the complete coil as constant, ignore wiring parasitics, and keep the inductance fixed. The decay equation is L(di/dt) + Ri + Vc = 0, giving t = (L/R) × ln[(R × Istart + Vc) / (R × Iend + Vc)]. Here L/R = 0.010 s.

Assumed suppressionReverse coil clamp VcTime: 60 → 15 mADriver node above 0 V
Plain diode0.7 V13.05 ms24.7 V
Diode + 24 V Zener24.7 V4.61 ms48.7 V

For the diode case, substitute t = 0.010 × ln[(24 + 0.7) / (6 + 0.7)] = 0.01305 s. For the second case, replace 0.7 V by 24.7 V: t = 0.010 × ln[(24 + 24.7) / (6 + 24.7)] = 0.00461 s. A larger reverse voltage brings this illustrative current to the same marker sooner.

The last column is just as important. In the illustrated low-side topology, the driver-side node rises to approximately supply voltage plus the reverse coil clamp: 24 + 24.7 = 48.7 V in the Zener example. A “24 V Zener” therefore does not limit that driver node to 24 V. These nominal values exclude supply variation, clamp tolerance and overshoot; they cannot establish compatibility with a particular output.

Actual relay inductance changes as the armature moves, and real suppressors do not hold a perfectly constant voltage. Contact transfer also depends on the magnetic and mechanical design. The table explains the electrical direction of the trade-off; it does not say that any real relay releases in 13.05 ms or 4.61 ms.

Separate command timing, relay release and load motion

“The relay is slow” can describe several different observations. The command may arrive late at the output, the coil current may decay slowly, the contacts may fail to transfer, or the downstream actuator may continue moving after contact opening. Treat those as separate boundaries.

Five diagnostic stages: PLC command, output and coil drive, decaying coil current, relay contact transfer, and downstream load response.
Figure 2. Diagnostic boundaries from command to load response. A status indicator or contact observation belongs to one part of the chain. Comparing the transitions locates the delay; the diagram does not assign a guaranteed time to any stage.

An output LED alone does not establish coil-current extinction or contact position. Likewise, a diode across a downstream solenoid affects that solenoid’s current decay, not necessarily the interposing relay coil. A fast relay contact can open while a separately suppressed solenoid continues to hold briefly.

ObservationWhat it points towardWhat separates the possibilities
Coil drive remains after the command changesOutput timing, program behavior or another feedCompare the command and electrical drive using the module’s documented signal behavior.
Drive is removed; coil current decays before contacts transferSuppression and relay release dynamicsIdentify the relay/socket suppressor and compare the actual assembly with applicable release-time data.
Coil current is gone; contacts remain in the operated stateMechanical or contact fault, or mistaken contact identificationVerify contact state and wiring under the relay manufacturer’s service procedure.
Contacts transfer; the load responds laterDownstream electrical or mechanical responseCheck the load’s own suppression, stored energy and operating behavior.

These are diagnostic branches, not fault verdicts. For example, a late contact opening does not by itself prove that the diode is wrong or that the contacts have welded. TE’s discussion of coil suppression and relay life2 explains why the installed combination matters when interpreting contact behavior.

Check the replacement assembly before changing the program

When a delay appears immediately after maintenance, start with what changed: the full relay suffix, coil supply, socket and plug-in suppression module. Two relays with the same nominal coil voltage and contact layout can have different suppression arrangements. A diode-equipped socket also makes polarity significant.

Omron’s MY relay transistor-drive FAQ4 is a useful concrete example: it recommends diode-equipped variants for that application, specifies correct polarity and notes a longer reset time. Its timing statements apply to the described MY products. They should not be turned into a universal release-time allowance for every 24 V relay.

  1. Identify the complete coil circuit. Record the output module, relay order code, socket and any suppression accessory. Use their diagrams to establish the coil polarity and whether the clamp is across the coil or driver. Do not infer the circuit from an LED or a matching socket shape.
  2. Locate the delayed transition. Prepare a controlled maintenance test that prevents unintended motion. Where electrical waveform measurements are needed, use qualified personnel and appropriately rated current or differential voltage probes; an ordinary grounded oscilloscope lead can change or short the circuit. Compare the command, drive removal and contact transfer before attributing the delay to suppression.
  3. Compare with the specified assembly. Check the relay’s release-time test conditions and whether they include the installed diode or suppressor. If a change is needed, select a manufacturer-supported arrangement against both the required response and the output’s inductive-load and voltage limits. Do not disconnect suppression as a trial fix.
  4. Retest the full sequence. After the identified correction, repeat the same timing observations with the intended load and operating conditions. Confirm contact transfer and downstream response, then restore the machine through its commissioning procedure. A faster coil-current decay alone does not prove the sequence now meets its requirement.

If the output command and electrical drive stop on time but the current and contacts release late, investigate the relay-and-suppression combination before shortening a PLC timer. If the contact already transfers on time, move the investigation downstream. The useful result is a located delay and a compatible correction, rather than a faster setting that hides an unexplained transition.

References

  1. TE Connectivity — Relay Coil Suppression with DC Relays
  2. TE Connectivity — Coil Suppression Can Reduce Relay Life
  3. Omron — General Purpose Relays FAQ02804
  4. Omron — General Purpose Relays FAQ02821

Replacing a relay and its socket?

Send the relay order code, coil voltage, socket and suppression accessory details. Xindustra can help identify the components to source for your specified assembly.

Discuss the relay assembly